Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
14 comments
2 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/22/2009
Emmerich battle! ID4 Wins!
on 8/29/2009
Hard to decide. These are two of the worst movies I've ever seen. I think the acting was somewhat worse in Day After Tomorrow.
on 10/9/2009
Independence Day. The villain--the alien threat--is much more tangible than random bad weather.
on 11/4/2009
Two of the best movies I have ever seen. :D Independence Day is even more awesome than Day After Tomorrow and also probably more realistic. If you can actually say that about any Emmerich film.
on 12/3/2009
The Day After Tomorrow was a terrible, terrible film.
on 1/1/2010
These are two movies with great effects and.... yeah... thats all. The movie with the fresh Prince was better
on 2/5/2010
i don't know, some reason i believe that such a magical tent exist more than i believe jeff goldbloom as a scientist.
on 3/6/2010
Same director same mindless action. ID does it without being so stupid, however.
on 7/2/2010
The problem with "Day After Tomorrow" is even if the politicos had heeded the scientists' warning, it wouldn't have mattered in such little time. It relies on audience empathy with the characters. I never connected with any of them to care whether they lived or died.
on 7/15/2011
Two of the more underrated films. Both people seem to hate, but both are very entertaining.
on 7/16/2011
Though not the best films in the world, I found them both extremely exciting and entertaining. But for me it's definintely The Day After Tomorrow.
on 8/27/2011
I love Independence Day. It's exciting and heartfelt. I can barely stand to sit through Day After Tomorrow.
on 9/12/2012
I don't think either are amazing, but Independence Day has that nostalgia factor going for it.
I'm not a huge ID4 guy....but this isn't even a discussion...
on 3/27/2014
ID4 is awesome love the action and flight scenes the cast is all-star its just one hell of a ride its a true guilty pleasure While Day After is dumb and boring with characters no one likes.
on 9/20/2014
Although I did find Independence Day to be cheesy in some parts, it was still fairly entertaining. It's lightyears ahead of Day After Tomorrow in my opinion.
