Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
7 comments
2 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 12/23/2009
Wow...Holocaust smackdown! I went with Schindler's List -- Speilberg's B&W seriousness has aged much better than Benigini's concentration clown schtick.
on 3/20/2010
I can only imagine how Hitler feels about this. Schindler's List was serious and brutal while Life Is Beautiful had a more silly and funny perspective. One is a masterpiece while the other is just a really good movie. I'm going with LIB mainly because of the entertainment value. LIB is a short, sweet, silly little film and I would rather prefer that to a much longer, serious, brutal holocaust film
on 1/29/2011
Im choosing Schindler's list. Though I have to admit its not an easy choice
on 6/22/2013
Schindler's List wins this one.
on 12/31/2013
I don't care how dumb this sounds but I'm picking Life is Beautiful...at least as of now. Schindler's List had an amazing last hour and a strong opening half hour but the middle, for me, dragged whereas Life is Beautiful movied along at a fantastic pace for the entire runtime.
on 1/5/2014
I'll go Schindler...
on 9/28/2014
life is beautiful. Schindler by far is the much for real and better made film but for myself personally i would sway to life is beautiful.
on 1/21/2015
REALLY tough choice as both are among the greatest Holocaust films ever made (which I account to being more triumphant and not being as overly-depressing as most movies of this genre), but edge goes to Schindler's List for its grander scale.
on 6/27/2015
Life is beautiful wins this match up. Roberto Benigni's amazing performance gives it the edge
on 9/17/2022
Both brilliant films but Schindler's List was more depressing than Life Is Beautiful.
on 10/8/2023
Roberto Benigni's performance is exquisite in LiB, but I have to go with Schindler's List
