Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
5 comments
6 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/26/2009
Are you kidding, how can I choose???
on 8/14/2011
By choosing Chinatown.
on 1/22/2012
Goodfellas by a nose
Gosh this is tough.Both are in my top 20.I think I'll go with Chinatown.
on 1/26/2012
Goodfellas is better than Chinatown.
Chinatown was good, but a little lackluster in my eyes despite its hype. GoodFellas exceeded my expectations - even for a ganster movie. Easy choice.
All the way with Zampa on this one. Chinatown was good, but didn't blow my mind. Goodfellas sticks with me all these years later...
on 4/2/2012
Chinatown for sure. I like GoodFellas a lot, but Chinatown both encapsulates everything about film noir from a '70s perspective, and then goes forward from that, basically creating the template for neo-noir. Anything that stands that perfectly at the center of one of my favorite genres has to get my vote. Plus, it's a damn fine good time at the movies.
on 7/13/2012
Gotta pick the '70s classic. Nicholson's best performance in my eyes.
on 9/25/2012
I suppose I can see how somebody else might love Chinatown but, to me, it was merely okay. GoodFellas obliterates it.
on 9/26/2012
Chinatown is the better film. GoodFellas is terrific, but Chinatown is in a whole other league that gives it the easy victory. Chinatown wins!
