Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/11/2009
Booyah! What happened to these guys? We need more sappy sports movies from them!
on 10/10/2011
Ah, the two David Anspaugh-Angelo Pizzo sports movies that redefined the genre. They're both great and timeless, but my vote goes for Rudy, especially considering that Jerry Goldsmith's score for that one takes it over the top (I was never much of a fan of Goldsmith's score for Hoosiers, so it hurts it enough to let Rudy take it).
Shocked? I'm from Indiana...so I think the answer is obvious. But wait...Notre Dame is in Indiana too. Even Rudy can't top Jimmy Chitwood and Hickory...
on 7/9/2014
Rudy i like more and routed for him more!
on 12/10/2017
Wow wow wow, this is a tough one. Both are in my top 100. Hoosiers is the better movie overall but I love them both.
on 9/8/2021
Close call. I'll go with Rudy due to the powerful underdog story, but Hoosiers is still pretty good with really good performances.
