Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
2 comments
5 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/17/2012
I love both but i'm giving the slight edge to Dogma here
on 9/11/2013
Probably Dogma. Mallrats was a tad too much of a Clerks re-thread for me. Dogma was fresh and original, for Smith, anyway.
on 4/24/2014
Dogma's probably the better movie, but I will always love Mallrats.
on 8/17/2017
Dogma is super pretentious. Mallrats is genuinely funny, yeah childish, but it's not like Dogma is a mature comedy about God....
Blasphemous DogCRAP versus genuinely humorous Mallrats featuring topless fortune telling and Stan Lee??? Not even a contest. Mallrats all day long.
on 9/4/2017
Mallrats for me. It actually had a plot that was half believable.
on 1/17/2020
Dogma is ok. Mallrats has some really funny stuff in it...easy choice.
