Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
13 comments
4 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/10/2009
Easily Toy Story.
on 11/15/2009
Both excellent Pixar. But I've watched Finding Nemo 20 times and I can watch it again and again. Ellie is way better than Buzz.
on 11/23/2009
Toy Story is much better
on 12/7/2009
Nemo was good, but you don't beat Toy Story.
on 12/16/2009
No question that Toy Story is a nearly perfect movie.
on 1/1/2010
Only two films have outdone Pixar's first, and one was its sequel. Toy Story has nostalgia in its favor, not to mention its sheer brilliance or how undeniably influential it happens to be. My intention is not to take anything away from Finding Nemo, though. It's another fine movie. Knew essentially nothing about it the first time I saw it. As a result, it had quite an effect on me, and still does to this day. But it can never compare to Toy Story.
on 3/7/2010
Comparing Pixar movies wth each other is an incredibly difficult task... But I'm giving it to Toy Story for now, because I liked it instantly, while Finding Nemo took awhile to grow on me.
on 4/15/2010
I also hate comparing Pixar movies. Many of them are all lumped together in my top 50, lol.
To infinity and beyond Fish Story.
on 8/5/2010
When you rank Pixar movies, you come up with a list in which the lowest ranked film is still really good. These are two of their absolute best. They are both milestones for animation.
As always, I hate to take anything away from another Pixar film, but Nemo is still far and away my favorite. Purely from a visual standpoint, it is Pixar's masterpiece; every frame of that film is jaw-droppingly beautiful. But it also really gets to me on an emotional level; I love the story. Toy Story is, of course, fantastic, but it's actually only about middle-of-the-road for me, as far as Pixar's films go. And, @twpk117, you're absolutely right: Even Pixar's worst movies are still great.
on 11/27/2010
Nemo is an epic in the truly literary sense of the word, however Toy Story gets the nod for its simplicity and heart.
on 8/18/2011
Toy Story is what started the whole Pixar generation! It wins.
Toy Story wins. But it took like 5 minutes staring at the screen before I could decide.
Charyou_tree has it exactly right, although I believe that Toy Story 3 may be the best. On the other hand (third hand) the original was a BRILLIANT idea.
on Jan 26
Toy Story is better acted lmao. TS >FN
Pixar's best against its worst. The math does itself.
