Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
1 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/3/2010
I love this match up this would make a really good double feature. I thought Shutter Island was really good but I have to go with Jack and the Cuckoo's nest here
on 1/28/2011
This is a great combination of movies. Cuckoo's Nest has stood the test of time, and is better overall.
on 10/23/2011
These two movies are basically inversions of each other. Shutter is good, but Cuckoo is superior
on 7/25/2012
Fun matchup, nice common ground these two have. This makes them perfect to compare. But the clear winner is the 75 classic! By quite some distance I might add.
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest for me as well, although I do enjoy Shutter Island a lot as well. I think Shutter Island is a little underrated I think.
(I wish we had an edit function...sigh)
on 7/26/2012
Without a doubt One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. Shutter Island is a really depressing movie and the soundtrack is pretty horrifying. Jack Nicholson is more superb than Leonardo Di Caprio as a lead actor and he really did deserve his accolades.
on 11/28/2012
I agree that Shutter Island is underrated, but this is an easy choice.
on 11/29/2012
Shutter Island
