Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
11 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 1/3/2010
Oh, snap. Okay, look, I love the Toy Story movies. But Pixar's just getting better and better. I was unbelievably moved by Up; I laughed, I cried, I kissed any pre-conceived notions of what an animated movie could or should be goodbye. The Toy Stories are masterpieces; Up kicks them to the curb.
on 4/12/2010
As much as I liked UP, I don't think it's Pixar's best. I think Toy Story 2 was better.
on 3/24/2011
Toy Story 2 is a dismal sequel. I wish I could figure out why they needed the cowgirl. And Up is just way overrated imo, but I'm still going with it.
Up packs quite the emotional wallop, but so does Toy Story 2. And Toy Story 2 has the benefit of being a sequel to one of my all-time favorites, meaning watching the movie was like seeing old friends again. It also far outclasses Up in the humor category, I feel. So, Toy Story 2.
on 9/4/2011
Toy Story 2 - nostalgic reasons.
As much as I like the Toy Story trilogy, TS2 is still my least favorite installment, I don't hate it or anything, but found it to be my least favorite. Up is awesome and charming in its own way.
on 11/3/2011
I actually cried more in TS3 than UP. Yep. True story.
I meant TS2, of course. Although I cried more in TS3 as well.
on 1/9/2013
Up :)
Woody and Buzz.
on 6/29/2013
TS 2 all the way. My favorite Pixar.
on 7/16/2013
TS2 for sure.
on 5/30/2014
going with my new favorite animated adventure - UP
on 7/23/2014
Up. I dunno really. Plain coin toss
Toy Story 2. Up after those first 10 mins got way too random and lame. Toy Story 2 in my opinion surpassed the original and remains Pixar's best (after Wall-E).
on 3/6/2015
Toy Story 2 is the best animation film
on 10/26/2018
UP
