Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
9 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/11/2009
Battle of the Pixars... really loved UP, esp. the first arc but not as enamored with the film as a whole. Still awesome but THE INCREDIBLES remains my favorite.
on 4/22/2010
There were parts of Up I absolutely loved, but the film didn't seem as fluid as I'm used to seeing from Pixar. Maybe I just have to watch it again. But for now, Incredibles.
Up is my high.
on 5/19/2011
Definitely The Incredibles. THe more I watch it, the more I realize just how well it works. Great films.
Up is quite average really. Some semi-sad shit happens at the beginning and then some more shit happens throughout. It wasn't funny or witty or fun. It dragged in some places. It's just kinda there.
Neither are near Pixar's best. I'm going with Up though....
UP
on 11/25/2011
WALL-E is better than both, but I'd rather watch a sweet tale than a violent social critic!
on 4/19/2012
UP is so much better than The Incredibles. No competition!
on Mar 26
The Incredibles...hands down.
The Incredibles is so much fun, and intelligently made. A witty script and exhilarating action scenes makes The Incredibles the king of super hero flicks. And as fantastic as The Incredibles is, it has nothing on Up. While many would argue that Up disappoints after it gets over it's masterful first 20 minutes, I found myself spellbound from beginning to end. Yes, the best of Up is conveyed in the first 20 minutes, but the rest of the film is still emotionally beautiful, elegant, and laugh-out-loud hilarious. I can't even begin to describe how much I love Up. Both films are absolute masterpieces, but Up is the better film, in my opinion.
Aside from the Toy Story Trilogy, The Incredibles is my favorite Pixar movie.
on Mar 27
The Incredibles is genius, Up isn't...At least, not for me
