Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
1 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 4/29/2011
Both have their flaws, and I almost want to give this one to Order of the Phoenix because "it has more Sirius Black in it". But Hallows pt 1 is just a better film.
on 6/30/2011
I think Phoenix is the weakest of the series. The movie and the book.
on 5/31/2012
Two of the three weakest Harry Potter movies (the other one being Goblet of Fire (and yes, I like the first two a lot for nostalgic reasons)). I guess Death Hallows: Part 1 wins. Order of the Phoenix felt soulless and rushed.
on 6/28/2016
I though Phoenix was an ok book, but as a movie Deathly Hallows P1 was more enjoyable, while Order of the Pheonix feels like a chore to watch
on 3/14/2017
Hair pot part 1
on 2/23/2022
I think the later the series got, the less fun and lovely the students were to each other. Really paints a portrait of PTSD. I'll go with Deathly Hallows for the cool backstory behind the invisibility cloak.
Gotta go with the Deathly Hollows....
on 8/13/2023
Those two are without a doubt the worst and most terrible Harry Potter movies ever. They both suck alot.
