Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
12 comments
22 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/20/2009
Unfair, both of these movies are in my top 10. Godfather 2, though I've seen Jaws a million times and it never gets old.
on 1/25/2011
Two of the very best films of the Seventies- this is tough. I'll favor Godfather Part II for now.
on 12/7/2011
Jaws wins for sure, Godfather is too booring and lengthy.
on 3/10/2012
Godfather for sure.
on 4/25/2012
Godfather....sorry Jaws...no hard feelings?
on 10/4/2012
The shark can't beat Michael Corleone.
on 10/5/2012
Part II is a far superior film to Jaws.
on 11/14/2012
Godfather 2 for it's storytelling and acting.
on 5/20/2013
I think Jaws has become a bit aged
on 12/16/2014
Jaws is a vastly entertaining film that deserves a lot of the praise it gets, the Godfather II deserves even more praise though.
Coin flip....going Jaws...
on 12/19/2014
tormaakechudi jaws
Of course TGF2 is the greater film, but that's not really what this site is about. I personally prefer watching Jaws.
on 12/20/2014
The Godfather Part II is better in almost every way
on 1/18/2015
Jaws is good but its not better than part II
on 5/19/2015
I'm going with Jaws.
on 7/23/2015
The Godfather Part II
on 10/8/2015
Fuck that shit, Jaws is just a film about a shark killing people, and no matter how well directed and executed it is, it cannot compete with an outstanding crime drama about the mafia, regarded as one of the best films of all time.
on 11/6/2015
The Godfather, Part II is a league above Jaws
on 2/23/2016
I can't see the why anyone would tamper a few match-ups, just like The Dark Knight ones, or these ones. Anyways, Jaws is the one I'd rather watch than Godfather 2.
on 7/14/2016
Jeez Danny didn't have to comment 10,608 times
Jaws!
on 11/20/2016
Jaws eats corleone family.
on 2/6/2017
Jaws is a solid movie, but godfather part 2 is a flat out masterpiece
on 11/7/2017
jaws is good, but i've never seen the hype for it. the godfather is as near perfect as its reputation suggests, even if i don't much like it
on 1/9/2018
Why do people have to spam these discussions? Anyway I was more into Jaws! The second Godfather is complete and utter mess of a film! Jaws is more coherent and engaging!
on 3/12/2018
If Jaws was in competition with the first Godfather film it would lose but Godfather 2 is inferior to Jaws.
on 5/22/2018
Jaws was rather sensational outstanding a better written story rather than Godfather II.
on 5/27/2018
Jaws Sucks!
on 4/11/2019
I know this is not a popular view but both suck and overrated. I would probably go with Jaws just cause shark is better than overrated mafia shit.
Jaws rules here but The Godfather 1 is still the flawless front runner.
Jaws is certainly far better than the most unpleasant overrated Godfather Part II which is no consider of best to compare of that to any film.
I really need to watch Jaws again...how does a shark swimming around and killing people compare to the story of two mob bosses played by two of the greatest actors of all time?
on 6/24/2020
Why is this being asked? Jaws is a phenomenal movie, but The Godfather is on another tier
Jaws was a phenomenal film and The Godfather was on another tier but Godfather 2 is inferior to Jaws.
on 1/4/2021
Jaws is perfect, but The Godfather Part II is far more powerful.
on 9/27/2022
Damn, hardest decision so far. Coppola on this one.
Part II easily and I love Jaws
on 4/2/2023
For me Jaws Win But The Godfather 2 Is very good