Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
5 comments
16 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 3/3/2010
BAM! This all comes down to how I rank the films as part of their individual trilogies. Unfortunately, I feel like they are each the second best. So nostalgia wins again, which certainly isn't very fair to a film that's only 9 years old (can you believe Fellowship is already 9?!)
on 7/21/2010
Lord of the Rings for me. The first part is still special as it showed that a movie version of LotR could actually work.
My favorite Indy vs. my favorite Rings. Damn. Last Crusade is in my Top 10, but Fellowship is my #1.
on 8/6/2010
Respective trilogies aside, I think LotR is simply a better film. Last Crusade has countless brilliant sequences and moments, but it can't match LotR's spectacular production and emotional impact.
on 8/7/2010
Damn, this is as close as it gets. These two movies are ranked at #3 and #4 on my flickchart. I think I like The Last Crusade somewhat better, but it's probably a toss-up.
Gotta give it to the Ring-Bearer.
on 2/23/2011
Easily my favorite Indiana Jones film and my least favorite LOTR film
on 11/21/2012
Fellowship takes my vote.
on 1/1/2013
Very close, but Fellowship it is.
on 1/2/2013
It's not to often I have to go against the Fellowship....but this is one of those times...
I love Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, it is probably my favorite Indiana movie, but nothing beats LOTR, it kind of trumps all other movies.
on 3/18/2013
Fav Indy vs Fav LOTR----LOTR wins for me
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring wins in a squeaker...
They're seperated by just a few spots in my top 20. Fellowship by a hair.
on 4/9/2013
LOTR easy
on 5/27/2013
Always....Fellowship. But I need to watch the Indy films again :D
on 9/10/2013
Fellowship is my favorite film of all time.
on 6/22/2014
LOTR all day
on 1/12/2017
Both philosophical quotes compared to two great films, but The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring wins, as well as Gandalf is the legendary wizard in this folk tale.
on 7/28/2018
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (
on 9/22/2018
Lord of the Rings over every Indiana Jones films...
on 2/20/2020
lord of the rings is better
