Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
20 comments
18 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/29/2009
Action-Thriller vs. Serial killer-Thriller?. Both movies from 2 of my favorite directors? Both modern classics? What to CHOOSE!?
on 3/28/2010
Reservoir Dogs, without blinking. Se7en was good, but Reservoir Dogs was fantastic.
on 4/19/2010
Se7en, hands freakin' DOWN! Love Reservoir Dogs though.
on 7/13/2010
I'm going to have to watch these two again to make a more informed decision but for now I think I will go with Seven
These both have permanent spots in my Top 50. I don't know if I can say I prefer one to the other right now so I'm going with whatever one I have ranked higher right now.
Seven left a bigger impression on me.
on 7/14/2010
Oh, Se7en, in a heartbeat. No movie has blown me away like it.
on 6/21/2011
Reservoir Dogs By a Nose
on 1/22/2012
God damn you Joe.Don't make me do this.
on 2/19/2012
Se7en.
on 5/22/2012
Reservoir Dogs is usually considered Tarantino's number two. Se7en is usually considered Fincher's number two. But I think both of these movies are better than Pulp Fiction and Fight Club. I love 'em. Anyway, Se7en wins. That movie left a gigantic impact on me, especially with its ending, even though it's mildly predictable.
Se7en. I haven't seen a movie that graphic and grisly in a very long time.
on 5/23/2012
Se7en. Often imitated...never duplicated.
on 5/30/2012
@MysticSpoon:I agree completely.Se7en has always been Fincher's best movie in my eyes.Don't understand the big deal about Fight Club.I love the whole look and feel of Se7en.Creates that decaying and haunting atmosphere.The entire movie is a thrill ride filled with tension and the ending just sealed the deal for me.Kevin Spacey's performance was brilliant.Reservoir Dogs is great as well and is very re-watchable but Se7en is just something special.
on 6/27/2012
I loved both endings, but Reservoir Dogs left me like, Oh my gosh, this is great because I like movies with endings like you don't know what happened to that character like Mr. Pink. Kevin Spacey was great as John Doe in Se7en. Tarantino wins
Tarantino will always outdo Fincher in Crime movies
I don't basically rank movies by which one I would rewatch the most, I rank it on the first time I saw the film and how good the story and characters are. Reservoir Dogs wins
@Connerwood1998 actually, you DO hear what happens to Mr Pink. You can hear him shout 'Don't shoot I got shot goddamnit' right before the ending. I guess he got captured by the police, because he didn't want to flee.
on 9/9/2012
A pretty good example of a movie that's too much a product of its decade vs. a movie that transcends its decade. Se7en feels all MTV-edgy-90s, like every other Fincher movie I've seen. Unwatchable for me.
(oh, and the mallcore theme song did not help)
Looks like every Fincher film from the '90s resembles an MTV video. Se7en in a landslide.
on 10/24/2012
DAMN
reservior dogs wins. But only just
Seven for me. Both are really good though.
on 11/25/2012
Pretty hard matchup. I think Se7en gets the slight nod for how intriguing the plot is.
on 4/7/2013
Dogs, but man it's close.
on 4/8/2013
This is pretty close. Two prominent masterpieces on my list, both top-of-the-line performances and story. I think Reservoir Dogs gets the win for the fact of being more entertaining.
on 4/29/2013
RD definitely
on 6/18/2013
Two ultra-violent darlings from the 90's. I suppose Se7en is quasi-independent, it certainly feels that way.
on 6/19/2013
Reservoir Dogs is up there in my top 10. Se7en isn't quite there.
on 8/28/2013
Switching to Se7en. Both top 25.
on 9/10/2013
Impossible to decide..
Reservoir Dogs.
on 10/13/2014
Reservoir Dogs is too Tarantino for Fincher.
on 7/4/2016
Reservoir Dogs. Tarantino is just too much for Fincher
Both films are 90's classics. But Dogs has the edge
Reservoir Dogs........
Mr. Pink>John Doe
on 4/24/2022
People should be ashamed to .mention Se7en in the same sentence as Reservoir Dogs. Se7en is a run of the mill detective flick.
on 9/4/2022
Reservoir Dogs was an amazing movie, but Se7en does take this one. Now, if this were Pulp Fiction...
on 12/6/2022
Love reservoir dogs but I love se7en more
on 1/8/2023
Se7en wins this but both are great
on 11/5/2023
Holy fuck this is hard. I'll say Reservoir Dogs for now.
