Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
1 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/2/2009
Classic vs classic, but TWoO wins.
on 8/17/2010
Two children's classics that have that lovely, shadowy, darker edge to them. It's another cinematic art that would appear to have been lost. Of the two Oz triumphs.
on 4/20/2012
There's no doubt for me that Poppins wins. I just can't get into Oz for some reason. It's somehow more cartoony than Poppins, despite the fact that Poppins partly takes place in a cartoon drawing.
on 4/21/2012
Wizard of Oz... but Mary Poppins is great.
on 10/20/2015
Wizard wins.
on 10/21/2015
Wizard of Oz by far. I watched that film all the time growing up. I never really was that much of a fan of Mary Poppins.
on 1/23/2017
Both musical films are great. I've never understood Mary Poppins. I'm going to go with The Wizard of Oz. It's just a classic.
on 4/4/2017
The Wizard of Oz trumps Mary Poppins. Dorothy and her friends take the victory on every musical movie so that the audiences won't even notice.
