Most Recent Discussions of "Slumdog Millionaire"

1

Nononsense

Nononsense

on Jul 18 had this to say:

"While a good watch, I find Slumdog's story to be ridiculously implausible. Way too much convenient coincidental happenstance to be taken seriously. At least with Up, you know you're watching an animated film that isn't dependent upon realism. I really like both movies, but for the reasons I mentioned, I'm giving Up the edge."